Adjudicators Anonymous 18/02/2014

Ice Dance © IOCAfter result fixing in ice dance was exposed at the 2002 Winter Olympics in Salt Like City, USA, the International Skating Union (ISU) set out to reform its judging.

Prior to Torino 2006 it adopted a new system in which the judges’ scores remained anonymous. A measure aiming to prevent pressure on individual officials by dubious outside influences!

The names of the nine judges on the panel are known and published alongside the results. But all public accountability for their scores is removed, as only the trimmed (highest and lowest scores are dropped) mean is posted. That ISU monitors the judges' individual scores in a post-event evaluation is certain. But having these scores out in the public domain seems to be one way of keeping officials under a positive pressure to be at their best with every call they make.

Results of Ice Dance | Free Dance in Sochi 2014

Results of the final of the 2013 GrandSlam Standard Final in Shanghai

If a deal was struck to trade favourable marks in the ice dance and team competitions (an allegation made prior to the Games in a report by French newspaper, L’Équipe), and the Eastern European judges voted as a bloc, they’d be able to affect the results even after the high and low scores get tossed.

However, because the judges’ scores are secret, no one outside the ISU can know if that’s in fact what happened.

The Globe and Mail, Canada







 

 

Latest NewsSubscribe to news RSS

  • Take Your Pick!

    Two "Live from ..." blogs offer coverage on a number of top-level DanceSport events held over the weekend. Some are held in China, others in Romania.

    20/09/2014 read more ...
  • GrandSlam Series 2015 - 2017

    The World DanceSport Federation reopens the bidding for one of the five regular legs of the GrandSlam Series 2015 – 2017. Submit bids by 15 Oct. 

    18/09/2014 read more ...
  • Looking Towards The Future

    One year after the inaugural World DanceSport Games concluded in Kaohsiung, TPE, WDSF is looking to find the hosts for future games.

    18/09/2014 read more ...
  • 2014 Prague World Open

    Heidi Goetz reports from the 2014 World Opens Latin and Standard held in Prague, CZE, on 13 and 14 September. And from the two PD Opens too! 

    18/09/2014 read more ...
  • Live from Wuhan, CHN

    A WDSF Communications team is currently in Wuhan, CHN, to report from the GrandSlam Latin and Standard that are held there on 13 and 14 September.

    12/09/2014 read more ...
  • 2014 King's Cup in Bangkok, THA

    For some, last weekend's King's Cup in the Thai capital Bangkok was the perfect warm-up for the GrandSlam that's coming up in Wuhan in four days.

    09/09/2014 read more ...
Archives